Vegan Leather, PU Leather, and Genuine Leather: Which One to Choose?

When you’re caught in the dilemma of choosing between genuine leather, PU leather, or vegan leather for your brand’s leather goods, it’s essential to first get a solid grasp of what each material brings to the table. This understanding will significantly influence your final decision.

The Journey of Leather Goods

Leather has been a reliable material since ancient tribal days, prized for its toughness and versatility, allowing people to craft all sorts of leather products. By the Middle Ages, leather had already become a staple across Europe, igniting a trend that would spread far and wide. As time passed, leather working techniques blossomed, introducing an ever-expanding array of colors and textures. What once started as a traditional craft has evolved into a fashionable, and sometimes artistic, product.

Today, leather isn’t just appreciated for its durability—it’s also a coveted fashion accessory, adding flair and sophistication to any wardrobe.

The art of leather working has kept up with changing times. Artisans continue to innovate, developing new techniques to meet the diverse needs of the market. Leather goods are now categorized into various types, each with its distinct characteristics and price ranges, perfectly in line with consumer demand.

Among the animal hides used in leather production, cowhide and sheepskin are the most commonly used. However, rarer and more exotic hides like crocodile, ostrich, snake, and lizard are also used to create high-end, one-of-a-kind products. These exotic skins offer their own special touch, often transforming an ordinary item into a luxury masterpiece, all driven by the designer’s creative vision.

6 Types of Leather You Should Know About

When it comes to genuine leather, there are three main types you should be aware of: full-grain leather, top-grain leather, and split leather. From my decade of experience in the leather goods industry, I can say these are the only true forms of leather. While the surface treatments may vary, the core material is always 100% animal hide.

Full-Grain Leather

Full-grain leather is the cream of the crop. It’s made from the finest hides with minimal imperfections. After being dyed, it’s sent straight to the factory without any additional chemical treatments or coatings. The leather retains its natural grain, complete with fine pores arranged irregularly, giving it a unique, organic texture. The surface is smooth, elastic, and breathable. It’s common to see natural growth marks, neck wrinkles, veins, and even small imperfections or unused belly areas. These blemishes are carefully avoided during cutting, resulting in higher material wastage. Due to its natural beauty and rarity, full-grain leather is the most expensive.

Top-Grain Leather

Top-grain leather undergoes some surface correction. Minor imperfections are removed through light sanding and repairs, followed by a protective coating to conceal any flaws. This type of leather still retains some natural characteristics, like irregular pores, but it feels firmer to the touch. Typically made from lower-quality hides, top-grain leather is considered a mid-to-high-end option. Thanks to the special treatment, top-grain leather has fewer visible imperfections, making it more efficient in production.

Split Leather

Split leather, also called secondary cowhide, is made from the lower layers of cowhide. It tends to be thicker and, to hide imperfections, it’s processed to resemble the outer layer. This leather retains some of the original elasticity and is highly versatile in its applications. High-quality split leather still boasts many of the physical properties of cowhide, including high tear strength, excellent resistance to folding, and durability against cold and mold. It’s easy to clean and maintains a similar structure to natural leather, making it ideal for a variety of uses. With a near 100% yield rate, it’s highly cost-effective.

Recycled Leather

Another option worth considering is recycled leather. Made from leftover scraps and waste leather, recycled leather maintains many of the qualities of genuine leather but at a much lower price point. The scraps are compressed into sheets and coated to imitate the surface of real leather. While it doesn’t have the same softness or durability as genuine leather, recycled leather can mimic the look of natural leather quite well, especially in textured finishes like litchi-grain or crosshatch patterns. One major drawback of microfiber leather is that, although its production process can simulate the texture of natural leather, current technology still has its limitations. For example, embossing, a common technique, uses molds to press patterns onto the surface of microfiber leather. However, the precision and complexity of the molds are limited, making it difficult to replicate the subtle grain and irregularities found in genuine leather. As a result, microfiber leather is better suited for applications like upholstery and automotive seat coverings, where the texture’s complexity is less critical.

Vegan Leather

As the name suggests, vegan leather is made from plant-based materials such as cactus, fruit peels, or tree bark fibers, instead of animal hides. Through innovative techniques, these materials are transformed into high-quality alternatives to traditional leather. For example, some types of vegan leather use waste from apples mixed with natural rubber, reducing waste and pollution. This process is an environmentally friendly way to repurpose agricultural by-products.

Unlike animal-based leather, vegan leather doesn’t involve any harm to animals, making it a popular choice for those who prioritize animal rights and sustainability. It’s completely free from animal products and can be classified as a type of synthetic leather. While it might not have the same durability as real leather, vegan leather continues to evolve and can be a more ethical and eco-friendly option.

PU Leather

Polyurethane (PU) leather, a type of synthetic leather, is widely used for fashion and practical goods. It has excellent appearance and texture, closely mimicking real leather. The material is soft, elastic, and smooth to the touch, offering a similar gloss and feel to genuine leather.

PU leather is highly versatile and can be easily cut, sewn, and shaped into various forms, making it a favorite for fashion designers. It can also undergo surface treatments such as coating or printing to enhance its aesthetic appeal. One of the key advantages of PU leather is its waterproof and moisture-resistant properties, making it suitable for use in various weather conditions.

Additionally, PU leather is non-toxic, odorless, and eco-friendly, meeting the demands of today’s consumers who care about health and environmental impact. While it’s cheaper than real leather, it offers a wide range of textures, styles, and color options, making it an accessible alternative to animal leather.

The types of leather differ greatly in both composition and craftsmanship, and naturally, their prices vary significantly.

Genuine Leather is priced per square foot. Typically, a full-grain cowhide leather sheet costs between $120-$180, depending on the thickness, craftsmanship, and leather yield. The size usually ranges from 25-28 square feet. Full-grain leather retains the natural texture and imperfections, which many premium brands prefer for its durability and aesthetic.

Top-Grain Leather retains some natural grain but is more processed. Though it lacks the pristine texture of full-grain, it offers better cost efficiency. This type of leather is often chosen by brands aiming for a good balance between quality and price. A top-grain cowhide leather sheet is priced around $100-$150, also covering 25-28 square feet.

Compared to the previous two, Split Leather is much more affordable. While it lacks the natural grain, it works well for items that need to hold a shape. Its surface is free from imperfections, allowing for greater material yield. The price typically ranges from $50-$80 per 25-28 square feet, depending on the style and finish.

Recycled Leather is the most affordable option. Although it contains some cowhide, its durability is compromised. The texture is often shallow and lacks the natural grain. This type of leather is sold by the meter, typically priced between $11.5-$14 per meter. Given that one meter is equivalent to about 15 square feet, it’s clear that the price difference compared to genuine leather is substantial.Anyway,

Vegan Leather, similar to recycled leather, is plant-based and does not contain any animal products. It undergoes a similar production process as recycled leather but tends to be marketed as an eco-friendly alternative. The price varies due to the lack of consistency in market value, with good-quality vegan leather typically priced between $5.7-$8.5 per meter.

PU Leather is a well-known synthetic leather, offering a wide range of styles and patterns. It is entirely man-made, which allows for the creation of various textures, including faux animal prints, digital prints, and holographic finishes. New technological surfaces can also drive up its price. Typical PU leather costs between $3.5-$4.5 per meter, depending on the style and finish.

From nearly a decade of experience, I’ve learned that using full-grain leather doesn’t always guarantee the best outcome. For some bag styles or shapes, split leather might be more suitable due to its firmer texture, helping achieve a better design. So, price should be considered as a reference, but it’s not always the determining factor in quality.

Does Genuine Leather Make the Best Quality Leather Goods?

In terms of value, yes, genuine leather tends to be the most durable and luxurious option. It’s long-lasting, develops character over time, and is often associated with high-end fashion. However, value is not solely determined by the material used. Design, craftsmanship, and how well the product complements the latest trends are equally important factors in determining a product’s worth.

From a business perspective, simply using expensive materials like genuine leather won’t guarantee success. If your product’s design doesn’t align with consumer tastes, or if it doesn’t meet the demand for fashionable items, consumers may not be willing to pay a premium price. Craftsmanship also plays a crucial role. High-quality stitching, edging, and finishing are all key to creating a product that stands out.

Even PU leather or vegan leather, when paired with excellent craftsmanship and contemporary design, can result in a high-quality product. So, rather than agonizing over whether to choose genuine leather, PU, or vegan leather, focus on your brand’s identity, the quality of design, and the overall craftsmanship. These are the true keys to your brand’s success.

Send messages to get more information